The Delhi High Court recently rejected a request for urgent consideration of a petition regarding the demolition of a building adjacent to the five-story Satya Niketan PG, which collapsed on September 6. During a hearing on Monday, a lawyer presented concerns that the demolition was proceeding without the debris from the fallen hostel being cleared, alleging that some individuals might still be trapped underneath.

The bench, consisting of Chief Justice DK Upadhyaya and Justice Tejas Karia, scrutinised the basis of the lawyer’s assertions. They noted that municipal authorities would have likely conducted a proper assessment prior to initiating such actions. The High Court indicated that the plea would be scheduled in the usual legal process rather than being addressed immediately.

When the lawyer sought urgent hearings, he reiterated claims that the demolition commenced without removing the debris from the hostel’s basement, raising concerns about potentially trapped individuals. However, the judges queried the evidence supporting these claims, emphasising the need for concrete information rather than mere speculation.

Judicial Skepticism Over Submissions

The judges challenged the lawyer to substantiate his claim regarding the possibility of people being trapped at the site. They inquired about the sources of information backing the assertion that individuals could still be located beneath the debris. The court highlighted the necessity for the lawyer to provide factual basis for the petition rather than assumptions.

It underscored that the authorities are presumed to have conducted an extensive technical audit before deciding to demolish the adjoining structure. During the exchange, the court expressed skepticism over the urgency of the petition, suggesting that it should not be filed without a reliable foundation.

The judges made clear their expectation that all submissions must be grounded in available technical data or assessments to warrant swift legal action. This incident follows the tragic events surrounding the collapse of the Satya Niketan building, which occurred while repair work was taking place. The High Court has previously ordered a high-level inquiry by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) into the circumstances that led to the disaster, which resulted in seven fatalities on the day of the collapse.

Background And Safety Concerns Raised

The collapse prompted the court to address broader issues related to inadequate housing facilities, specifically concerning hostels managed by local universities and the government. The court noted that this incident not only highlighted the tragedy of those affected but also raised significant concerns about the safety and maintenance standards of living accommodations for students.

In the wake of the collapse, on September 8, the MCD initiated a controlled demolition of the adjacent structure housing a girls’ paying-guest accommodation. Following the incident, this facility was deemed dangerous and subsequently evacuated to ensure the safety of the residents.

The obligation of the government and municipal organisations to ensure safe living conditions has come under scrutiny as a result of this event. The ongoing legal proceedings and inquiries are expected to shed further light on the responsibilities of the MCD and the necessity for stringent regulations in the establishment and maintenance of paying-guest accommodations across the region.

Long or Short, get news the way you like. No ads. No redirections. Download Newspin and Stay Alert, The CSR Journal Mobile app, for fast, crisp, clean updates!

App Store –  https://apps.apple.com/in/app/newspin/id6746449540 

Google Play Store – https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.inventifweb.newspin&pcampaignid=web_share