Tigmanshu Dhulia has expressed his concerns regarding the storytelling quality of the ‘Dhurandhar’ franchise, despite its financial success. The series has reportedly surpassed the Rs 3,000 crore mark globally, establishing itself as one of the most significant Hindi film franchises in recent years. However, Dhulia suggests that the success does not reflect innovative storytelling but rather a reliance on familiar formulas.

During his remarks at The Wire’s event, The State of Media and Film Industry, Dhulia highlighted a perceived trend within Hindi cinema that favours a corporate-driven approach. He remarked that filmmakers tend to confine themselves to a single template, resulting in a lack of originality in the narratives presented. This critique extends to other popular franchises like ‘Pushpa’ and ‘KGF’, which he labels “fictional biopics”.

Dhulia acknowledged the entertainment value of the first ‘Dhurandhar’ film, commending its presentation, music, and pacing. However, he raised a pivotal question regarding the core story of the film, implying that the narrative lacks substance. The filmmaker pointed out that while the film may be visually impressive, it ultimately lacks a compelling storyline that resonates with audiences.

Corporate Culture’s Impact on Film Narratives

According to Dhulia, the prevalence of extreme capitalism within the film industry is undermining creative individuality. Filmmakers with unconventional ideas face significant barriers, often being discouraged from pursuing original storytelling due to the dominance of a standardised template. He expressed concern about the disappearance of true storytellers, suggesting that the industry is becoming increasingly homogenised.

Dhulia articulated that the ongoing trend in film is a reflection of broader societal changes, where individual characteristics and diverse narratives are being overshadowed. He used his hometown of Allahabad as an example, describing how its unique identity has gradually diminished over time, mirroring the trend observed in the film industry.

This commentary on the filmmaking landscape raises critical questions about the direction of Hindi cinema. While franchises like ‘Dhurandhar’ achieve remarkable box-office figures, the underlying narrative choices may warrant deeper reflection. Dhulia’s perspective suggests a desire for a return to more varied and meaningful storytelling, rather than the mere replication of successful formulas.

‘Dhurandhar’: Box-Office Success

The ‘Dhurandhar’ franchise, featuring Ranveer Singh as an undercover operative, blends action and drama as it navigates themes of espionage and national security. Alongside actors such as Akshaye Khanna and Sanjay Dutt, the series has captivated audiences, leading to its remarkable financial achievements.

The franchise’s success presents a juxtaposition to Dhulia’s critique, as he questions whether commercial viability equates to genuine innovation in storytelling. As the debate over the state of Hindi cinema continues, Dhulia remains a notable voice advocating for a renewed emphasis on authentic narratives. His upcoming project, ‘Ghamasaan’, set to premiere on September 11, is anticipated to showcase a different approach.

It highlights his ongoing commitment to storytelling that transcends commercial norms. In essence, Dhulia’s comments elevate ongoing discussions about the intersection of art and commerce in Bollywood, raising important considerations about how films are made and the stories that are told. The question of whether successful financial returns can coexist with meaningful storytelling continues to resonate within the industry.

Long or Short, get news the way you like. No ads. No redirections. Download Newspin and Stay Alert, The CSR Journal Mobile app, for fast, crisp, clean updates!

App Store –  https://apps.apple.com/in/app/newspin/id6746449540 

Google Play Store – https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.inventifweb.newspin&pcampaignid=web_share