The Supreme Court has upheld the cancellation of a ‘ryotwari patta’ associated with land designated as a government water body in Tamil Nadu. The ruling was announced on October 16 by a bench comprising Justices SVN Bhatti and NV Anjaria. The court directed the state government to allocate a suitable alternative site to the owners of twenty flats prior to any demolition of their residences.

A ‘ryotwari patta’ serves as an official land record issued to individual cultivators, confirming their rights to occupy and cultivate specific land while remitting taxes directly to the government. Justice Bhatti, who authored the judgment, noted that the flat owners had been misled into believing that the state had no claim over the land, based on official documents and revenue records.

The bench expressed concern over the potential hardship that could arise from demolishing the flats without considering the financial implications for the owners. It stated that such actions could result in irreparable financial harm and displace families. To mitigate possible hardships, the court instructed the Chief Secretary of Tamil Nadu and the District Collector of Tiruvallur to provide a vacant site of equivalent value to the flat owners, ideally within six months.

Background of the Dispute

The case pertains to a specific parcel of land in Thirumullaivoyal village, located in Tiruvallur district, which was recorded in the 1911 resettlement register as “Government Poramboke – Kanakkan Kuttai.” This disputed land is part of a larger plot measuring 1.68 acres. The controversy emerged when the Tiruvallur district revenue officer granted a ryotwari patta for 0.72 acres to P Ramadoss in January 2011.

Subsequently, the land was involved in property transactions and development activities, including the construction of twenty residential flats. Tamil Nadu Mercantile Bank extended credit facilities amounting to Rs 3.40 crore based on a mortgage secured over this land. However, in December 2019, the commissioner of land administration annulled the patta after determining that it had been issued in contravention of legal provisions.

The Madras High Court later affirmed the cancellation and mandated the removal of unauthorised structures, as well as the restoration of the water body. The Supreme Court, in rejecting the appeals filed by a flat owner and Tamil Nadu Mercantile Bank, observed that the earliest revenue records classified the land as a tank and government poramboke, not as ryoti land eligible for a patta.

Final Ruling and Implications

The Supreme Court’s ruling confirmed the cancellation of the patta and the restoration of the land as a water body. The court also reiterated the necessity for the Tamil Nadu government to provide an appropriate alternative site for the flat owners before any demolition takes place. This decision aims to ensure that the rights of the flat owners are considered while upholding the legal status of the land.

The judgement underscores the importance of adhering to established legal frameworks concerning land use and ownership in Tamil Nadu. It reflects the judiciary’s commitment to protecting public resources while balancing the rights of individuals involved in property transactions.

As the case unfolds, the state government is expected to act promptly in accordance with the court’s directives, ensuring that the flat owners receive the support they require during this transitional period. The implications of this ruling may extend to future land use policies and the enforcement of regulations concerning government water bodies.

Long or Short, get news the way you like. No ads. No redirections. Download Newspin and Stay Alert, The CSR Journal Mobile app, for fast, crisp, clean updates!

App Store – https://apps.apple.com/in/app/newspin/id6746449540

Google Play Store – https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.inventifweb.newspin&pcampaignid=web_share