Indian Democracy Cannot Fit 1 Shoe On 20 Different Feet

The CSR Journal Magazine

In a village I will call Sonpur, an old woman named Kamlabai keeps a photograph of a bridge that does not exist. A contractor’s board stands where the bridge should be. It carries a sanctioned amount, a date of completion that passed 6 years ago, and the name of a minister who has since been promoted to a different ministry and a different set of promises. The river below keeps flowing, and the children of Sonpur still cross it in a rowing boat each monsoon, holding their school bags above their heads like small, solemn flags.

Kamlabai has voted in every election since she was 21. She has pressed the button for the lamp, the lotus, the hand, the broom and the bicycle. Each time she was told that this was the day her voice mattered. Each time, once the ink dried on her finger, her voice was collected like rainwater in a government tank and carried off to a city she has never seen. She does not hate democracy. She is simply tired of being a guest in it.

To understand Kamlabai’s bridge, you must go back to a tailor’s shop in London, and to a coat.

The tailoring of a borrowed coat

The Westminster system was stitched over centuries for a particular body: a small island, a homogeneous electorate, a long habit of deference, and a class of gentlemen who could be trusted to sit in a room and argue on behalf of everyone else. It fit that body the way a bespoke coat fits the man it was measured for. It was never a universal garment.

When India became free, we were handed this coat and told it was the very definition of modern democracy. We wore it because it was the finest thing in the colonial wardrobe and because we had watched our rulers wear it for two centuries. Nobody asked whether a coat cut for the English drizzle would suit the monsoon, the desert and the Himalayan snow all at once. We buttoned it over a billion bodies and called the result a nation.

The Constituent Assembly did not entirely forget the alternative. The Gandhian proposal of a village-based democracy was on the table. Scholars note that the framers of the republic adopted the parliamentary form of government in preference to the Gandhian proposal of village-based democracy. The coat won, and the sketch of a different garment was folded away in a drawer.

What the old man saw?

Gandhi had seen the coat up close, and he was unimpressed. In Hind Swaraj, written in 1909, he developed what remains one of the sharpest attacks on parliamentary government in our political literature. He was not merely sneering at a foreign fashion. He feared that the British parliamentary model could turn into an anti-people institution in a multi-religious and multicultural land, and he preferred direct participation over distant representation. He had a famous image for the parliament at Westminster, one that his critics never forgave, and his admirers never forgot: a sterile woman and a prostitute, he called it, dependent on every changing mood and every passing master. The words were harsh and the metaphor was uncomfortable, but the diagnosis was precise. A body that answers to no one, whose loyalty is rented by whoever holds the whip, will never become the servant of the people.

His alternative was beautiful in its simplicity. He asked us to stop imagining the nation as a pyramid with a few people at the apex and millions crushed beneath. He offered the oceanic circle instead. In his own words, the structure would be made of innumerable villages, in ever-widening, never-ascending circles, where life will not be a pyramid with the apex sustained by the bottom. A pebble dropped in a pond sends ripples outward, and each ripple is as real as the one before it. The individual sits at the centre, the village around her, the district around the village, the nation around the district. Power does not climb upward and vanish. It radiates outward and returns.

He was not alone in his unease. Vinoba Bhave walked across the country asking landlords to give away land, trusting the village conscience more than the legislative committee. Jayaprakash Narayan, the old socialist turned moral insurgent, spent his final decades pleading for what he called party-less democracy, a politics that began in the village assembly and climbed upward by consent rather than by conquest. M. N. Roy, once Lenin’s favourite Indian, drew up a plan of local people’s committees, pyramids of direct citizen participation from the bottom upward. Ram Manohar Lohia dreamed of a four-pillar state in which village, district, province and centre each held real, constitutionally protected power. These men disagreed about almost everything else. They agreed that the coat did not fit.

The cost of a five-year lease

Now consider how the coat works in practice. In a parliamentary democracy, the citizen signs a lease. For five years she hands her sovereignty to a representative, who then hands his judgment to a party, which hands its discipline to a leader. By the time the chain reaches the actual decision, the citizen is four links removed from the thing she voted about. She cast her ballot over the question of a bridge, and the person deciding the question of the bridge is thinking about a coalition.

The anti-defection law, introduced in the name of stability, tightened the chain further. A legislator who votes his conscience against his party risks losing his seat. So, the parliament of the world’s largest democracy has become, in too many debates, a chamber where outcomes are known before the first speaker rises. The speeches are theatre. The division bell is a formality. The citizen watching the proceedings is like a man peering through the window of a restaurant, reading the menu but never allowed to order.

Then there is the arithmetic of the first-past-the-post system, another gift of the same tailor. It allows a government to command a commanding majority of seats while holding a minority of the national vote. A party can win the keys to Delhi with the affection of fewer than one in three voters, and rule as though it carried the whole country on its shoulders. The majority that did not vote for it is invited to wait five years for another turn. To a nation as plural as ours, this is not a quirk. It is a daily cut inflicted on the idea of representation.

And the lease is renewed because of a single-day performance. A voter must compress her views on healthcare, caste, the border, the rupee, forest rights, the price of onions and the dignity of her daughter into one press of a button. The system hands her a thousand-page menu and permits her to point at exactly one dish. Whichever dish she points to, she receives the entire banquet, including the items she would never order.

The villages that kept the faith

Contrast this with what happens when ordinary people are handed the pen. Switzerland is the example most often held up, and not because the Swiss are saints. They are not. It is because they decided, in the middle of the nineteenth century, that sovereignty belonged to the citizen and that parliament was her employee. Swiss voters usually go to the polls on national issues four times a year, and referendums are also held regularly at cantonal and municipal levels. The citizen does not merely choose the cook. She tastes the soup.

The results are not dramatic in the way revolution is dramatic. They are dramatic in the way a well-kept garden is dramatic. Researchers have found that Swiss direct democracy better reflects what citizens want, because the public can shape the laws. The mere existence of the referendum, the threat that a law can be challenged by signatures, forces the parliament to negotiate with society before it legislates rather than after. The Swiss legislator writes with one eye on the voter, because the voter holds a veto. The system is, in effect, a permanent conversation, and a conversation produces a different kind of country than a monologue does.

Elsewhere the same logic has been tried in new clothes. Taiwan, after its Sunflower Movement, built digital platforms through which citizens and officials deliberated on thorny questions, such as how ride-hailing should be regulated, until consensus began to emerge from the noise. Ireland handed some of its most divisive moral questions to a citizens’ assembly of ordinary people chosen by lot, who studied evidence for weekends on end and produced recommendations that later went to a national referendum. The country that had been tearing itself apart over certain questions for decades found a settlement, and the settlement held. In both cases the lesson was the same. When you trust citizens with real decisions and give them real information, they do not behave like a mob. They behave like jurors.

India has its own seeds of this garden, though we have kept them locked in a shed. The 73rd Amendment gave the Gram Sabha a constitutional home. Then, in a remote corner of Odisha, the seed sprouted. In the Niyamgiri hills, after the Supreme Court’s 2013 ruling, the Dongria Kondh gram sabhas rejected bauxite mining, and the Union government then refused clearance. A tribal community, voting in open assembly, stood in front of a mining giant and said no, and the machinery of the state respected the voice. It was perhaps the nearest we have come to Gandhi’s oceanic circle in the modern era. It was also a reminder that the circle can work, when someone is willing to let it.

Why now, and why India?

Every age has its own bottleneck, and ours is speed. A century ago, a representative could plausibly claim that the voter could not follow the debates, could not read the bills, could not gather in one place. The coat was a technology for a world of slow roads and scarce information. That world has vanished. A farmer in Vidarbha today carries in his pocket more access to information than a Member of Parliament did in 1950. A woman in a Bengaluru flat can verify a budget line in the time it takes to boil rice. Insisting that such citizens must hand their judgment to professional proxies for five years is like insisting that a modern traveller must book every journey through a telegraph clerk.

And India is not merely larger than Britain. It is stranger. Our states are the size of European nations, with their own scripts, harvests, grievances and gods. A single decision made in a central chamber, however well meant, lands on twenty different realities like a single shoe thrown at twenty different feet. What the Himalayan village needs from forest law is not what the Konkan fisherman needs from coastal law. A system that routes every question through one capital, one party calculus and one leader’s mood will fail many of the feet it was supposed to fit.

There is also the matter of trust, which is the true currency of a democracy, and which is steadily being devalued. Citizens increasingly feel that elections are a spectacle in which the real decisions are taken elsewhere, by donors, by consultants, by whoever can afford the loudest megaphone. A nation that begins to believe its vote is decorative will eventually stop believing in its vote. Direct democracy is, among other things, a repair kit for that trust. When the citizen can propose a law, challenge a law and recall a representative who has betrayed her, the ballot stops being a lottery ticket and becomes a lever.

Sketching a different garment

What would a Indian version looks like? Not a copy of Switzerland, because we have learned our lesson about copying. It would begin where Gandhi began, at the village and the ward, with Gram Sabhas and Mohalla Sabhas empowered to decide budgets, not merely to hear them. It would move to the district and the state, where citizens could initiate legislation by collecting signatures, and where major laws and big infrastructure projects would face a mandatory public vote. It would include the right of recall, so that a representative who sells the voter’s trust can be returned to private life before the 5-year lease expires. It would use digital tools with care, to lower the cost of participation, while guarding against the quiet ways that technology can be bent. And it would keep a constitutional fence, the one Ambedkar insisted upon, so that no majority could vote away the rights of a minority.

It would be slower in some ways and faster in others. A bridge for Kamlabai would not wait for the stars of a coalition to align. It would be put on the village agenda, funded in the open, and tracked by the very people who will cross it. If the bridge failed, there would be no distant minister to blame, only a decision the village made together and could unmake together. That is not a smaller democracy. It is a larger one, because it turns the passenger into the driver.

The garment and the wearer

A coat does not exist for its own sake. It exists to keep a body warm. When the coat begins to pinch, restrict and humiliate the body, the sensible response is not to praise its stitching. It is to ask what the body needs and cut a new one. India is not a guest at a Westminster banquet. It is a civilisation older than the idea of parliament itself, with a village assembly tradition that predates the Magna Carta by centuries. We do not need to apologise for wanting a democracy that fits.

Kamlabai will, God willing, see her bridge one day. But the point is not the bridge. The point is that she should not have to wait for a minister to remember a promise. She should hold the pen herself. The old man in the loincloth saw this a hundred years ago, from a distance that looked like eccentricity and now looks like foresight. The coat has served its time. It is time to let the circle widen.

Views of the author are personal and do not necessarily represent the website’s views.

Dr. Jaimine Vaishnav is a faculty of geopolitics and world economy and other liberal arts subjects, a researcher with publications in SCI and ABDC journals, and an author of 6 books specializing in informal economies, mass media, and street entrepreneurship. With over a decade of experience as an academic and options trader, he is keen on bridging the grassroots business practices with global economic thought. His work emphasizes resilience, innovation, and human action in everyday human life. He can be contacted on jaiminism@hotmail.co.in for further communication.

Long or Short, get news the way you like. No ads. No redirections. Download Newspin and Stay Alert, The CSR Journal Mobile app, for fast, crisp, clean updates!

App Store – https://apps.apple.com/in/app/newspin/id6746449540

Google Play Store – https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.inventifweb.newspin&pcampaignid=web_share

Latest News

Popular Videos